A collection of Black Tap’s greatest hits
Cover A collection of Black Tap’s greatest hits
A collection of Black Tap’s greatest hits

The Tatler Dining team conducts a taste test of Black Tap's menu at its new Sunway Resort Hotel location

The arrival of Black Tap Craft Burgers & Shakes, a New York City institution, injected excitement into the local dining scene with its award-winning burgers and extravagant milkshakes.

Located at Sunway Resort Hotel, it welcomes diners with vibrant neon signs and thumping hip hop music, creating a space that is fun and lively to enjoy a slice of Americana. On its menu are 10 different beef burgers, a handful of chicken sandwiches, a wide range of snacks and wings, and more than 15 milkshakes, including the signature CrazyShakes (and yes, it is as wild as it sounds). 

Read more: Inside the newly opened Black Tap at Sunway Resort with Chris Barish, founder of the global chain

Tatler Dining had the privilege of having the first taste of Black Tap’s offerings before its opening. Read on for our verdict.

White Miso BBQ Wings

Tatler Asia
The White Miso BBQ wings are a great way to start your meal at Black Tap
Above The White Miso BBQ wings are a great way to start your meal at Black Tap
The White Miso BBQ wings are a great way to start your meal at Black Tap

Slathered in a white miso-based barbecue sauce and fried to crispy golden perfection, these White Miso BBQ wings are hands down one of the standout dishes. The meat is juicy and tender, and the breading crunchy. The miso sauce is balanced with a nice touch of umami and a velvety creamy texture. 

The wings are packed with flavour and best eaten fresh off the stove. It’s a definite must-have.

Salted Egg Yolk Chicken Sandwich

Tatler Asia
The Salted Egg Yolk Chicken Sandwich is ideal for anyone who loves a good crunch
Above Salted Egg Yolk Chicken Sandwich
The Salted Egg Yolk Chicken Sandwich is ideal for anyone who loves a good crunch

A nod to the local palate, the Salted Egg Yolk Chicken Sandwich is a wonderful surprise. The salted egg yolk and red chillis elevated the sandwich with an addictive salty-sweet taste. The accompanying calamansi coleslaw and coriander stalks add a welcome hint of freshness and acidity. For someone who has really high standards for chicken sandwiches, this passed with flying colours.

See also: 7 local garnish brands you need to know

Thai Green Curry Chicken Burger

Tatler Asia
The Thai Green Curry Chicken sandwich hits all the right notes
Above The Thai Green Curry Chicken
The Thai Green Curry Chicken sandwich hits all the right notes

In another fantastic nod to Southeast Asia, this burger is made up of a spiced chicken patty, creamy Thai green coconut curry sauce, cashew nuts, tangy garlic lime aioli with cilantro, and some chopped red chillies.

The patty is moist and juicy, and the curry makes for a wonderful pairing, easily one of the most unique burgers we’ve ever had.

The Greg Norman

Tatler Asia
The Greg Norman is a classic burger you need to order at Black Tap
Above The Greg Norman is a classic burger you need to order at Black Tap
The Greg Norman is a classic burger you need to order at Black Tap

The Greg Norman was crowned New York City Wine & Food Festival’s Burger Bash People’s Choice Award winner three times in the last few years—and we can see why. Consisting of Australian Wagyu beef patty cooked to a chef’s medium, melted blue cheese, and a pile of rocket seasoned with olive oil and apple cider vinegar. On the side is a serving of buttermilk dill sauce.

It’s one of the items we are most excited to try and it doesn't disappoint. The patty is grilled perfectly, leaving a little crust on the outside and incredible umami and juiciness on the inside. 

Don’t miss: The best hawker breakfast in Malaysia, according to chefs

The Wagyu Steakhouse Burger

Tatler Asia
The Wagyu Steakhouse Burger is one of Black Tap’s award-winning burgers
Above The Wagyu Steakhouse Burger is one of Black Tap’s award-winning burgers
The Wagyu Steakhouse Burger is one of Black Tap’s award-winning burgers

The winner of the Judges’ Choice Award at the NYC Wine & Food Festival’s Burger Bash in 2021, the Wagyu Steakhouse Burger is served with a Wagyu patty, pepper jack cheese, A.1. Steak Sauce, crispy onions, and beef bacon, topped off with roasted garlic mayonnaise.

This burger is a clear favourite with the dining team thanks to the hint of smokiness from the bacon and crispiness from the onions. The pepper jack cheese spices things up further.

Kimchi Shrimp Burger

Tatler Asia
The Kimchi Shrimp Burger is perfect for anyone who loves seafood and the tang of kimchi
Above The Kimchi Shrimp Burger
The Kimchi Shrimp Burger is perfect for anyone who loves seafood and the tang of kimchi

One of the handful of burgers in Black Tap’s lineup that doesn't feature a beef patty is the Kimchi Shrimp Burger, made with a shrimp patty, kimchi coleslaw, garlic and lime aioli, sesame seeds, and scallions.

The lime zest and lime juice in the patty cut through the sweetness of the shrimp, the refreshing taste pairing well with the kimchi coleslaw, which is a delight on its own.

Read more: 5 bars in Johor Bahru for a nice drink

Chilli Crisp Classic Shake

Tatler Asia
The Chilli Crisp Classic Shake is a Malaysia-exclusive shake that you can't miss
Above Chilli Crisp Classic Shake
The Chilli Crisp Classic Shake is a Malaysia-exclusive shake that you can't miss

Of all the Classic Shakes on the menu, this one caught our eyes immediately because we never ever expected to be having a milkshake made with Lao Gan Ma chilli crisp. Made exclusively for the Malaysian outpost, it’s a daring combination of vanilla ice cream topped with whipped cream, an extra drizzle of the chilli crisp, and a cherry. 

It isn’t as spicy as we think, although every sip is an unorthodox marriage of flavours that somehow work.

Cinnabon Shake

Tatler Asia
The Cinnabon CrazyShake will appease any cinnamon fan out there (Photo: Instagram/@blacktapmy)
Above The Cinnabon CrazyShake will appease any cinnamon fan out there (Photo: Instagram/@blacktapmy)
The Cinnabon CrazyShake will appease any cinnamon fan out there (Photo: Instagram/@blacktapmy)

Calling all cinnamon roll fans! The Cinnabon Shake is one of Black Tap’s all-time favourites Crazy Shakes that blends the flavours of cinnamon and vanilla together. Not only is the CrazyShake topped with a whole mini Cinnabon, it also has a vanilla frosted rim with bits of Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal. 

This classic flavour combo was our favourite CrazyShake of the day, winning us over with its nice balance between the sweet vanilla and the woody flavours from the cinnamon.

See also: 5 things you might not know about gelato

CakeShake

Tatler Asia
The CakeShake is one of Black Tap’s most well-known CrazyShakes
Above The CakeShake is one of Black Tap’s most well-known CrazyShakes
The CakeShake is one of Black Tap’s most well-known CrazyShakes

Perhaps Black Tap’s most famous CrazyShake, the CakeShake features a cake batter base and is topped with a whole slice of funfetti cake. The cheerful appearance is completed with a vanilla frosted rim with rainbow sprinkles. 

This Crazy Shake literally takes the cake for being the most extravagant milkshake we’ve had to date, and we enjoy it thoroughly.

NOW READ

The best croissants in the Klang Valley, according to pastry chefs

By the glass: Jordan Lim, Beam Suntory brand ambassador

The best wonton noodles in Hong Kong, according to Chinese chefs

Credits

Photography: Daniel Adams & Ravin Shanmugarajan

Topics

Amanda Fung
Writer, Tatler Dining, Tatler Malaysia
Tatler Asia
Amanda Fung

Amanda is a KL-born and raised third culture kid, who lives to eat. If not found reading, writing for Tatler Dining, or snacking, she is most likely playing with her dog, Katsu, sourcing new Birkenstocks, or looking for a new restaurant to venture to. 

Follow her on Instagram at @feedingamanda.