Cover Georgia Benjamin’s vintage watch collection (Photo: courtesy of Georgia Benjamin)
Georgia Benjamin’s vintage watch collection (Photo: courtesy of Georgia Benjamin)
1 / 1
Georgia Benjamin—collector, influencer, and devoted obsessive—on building a vintage watch collection that is undeniably and unapologetically you
For Georgia Benjamin, a proper vintage watch collection is a diary of moments, moods and cities. For her, it began with a two-tone Cartier Santos Galbée spotted in a New York shop window and traded for on the spot, and has since grown into a collection built on instinct as much as research: a self-imposed three-week rule, an obsession with the Cartier Crash, and a soft spot for Rolex’s off-catalogue surprises.
Here, Benjamin tells Tatler about her three-week rule, her grail watch, and why she'd rather own thirty pieces she loves than one she bought to impress someone else.
In case you missed it: Exclusive: Lenny Kravitz on the Jaeger-LeCoultre Reverso and why he waits for music instead of chasing it
Above Benjamin’s started her vintage watch collection with a Cartier (Photo: courtesy of Georgia Benjamin)
Benjamin’s started her vintage watch collection with a Cartier (Photo: courtesy of Georgia Benjamin)
1 / 1
How do you identify your own “watch personality,” and how has it changed over time?
Vintage yet timeless, design-forward, ideally on a bracelet, and always a conversation starter. If my collection were a person, they’d be classic but with a strong point of view. Think heavy yellow gold, a 70s or 80s sensibility, a Parisian elegance, but always something that makes you do a double take. There’s always a surprise in there somewhere. It wasn’t always this focused. Early on I was more erratic about it. I’d get excited about something I’d never seen before and disappear down a rabbit hole. That instinct is still there, but now it’s filtered through years of collecting and a much stronger design point of view. I know which Patek [Philippe] pieces I reach for. That tenure changes how you see everything.
Which vintage watch styles or brands naturally resonate with your personal aesthetic and why?
Cartier was my entry point. My very first watch was a two-tone Santos Galbée that I spotted in a shop window in New York and essentially traded pieces to afford. That moment set the tone. I love Cartier for its architecture; the cases feel like jewellery and sculpture at once. The Crash in particular is something I’m deeply obsessed with. I’ve even made my own papier mâché version as a working wall clock. I also love Rolex, but specifically for its classicism and the off-catalogue surprises, the unexpected twists tucked within such an iconic house. The tension between classic and unexpected is exactly what resonates with me. And 70s Piaget, the bracelets from that era are just epic. Integrated, architectural [and] unapologetically bold. Anything with a strong design point of view tends to stop me in my tracks. My grail remains the Vacheron Constantin 222. Very much an ‘if you know, you know’ watch.
Above Georgia Benjamin (Photo: courtesy of Georgia Benjamin)
Georgia Benjamin (Photo: courtesy of Georgia Benjamin)
1 / 1
How do you balance buying for emotional appeal versus buying for financial upside?
Emotion leads, always. I have a full- time job in tech, so I’m not buying watches as a financial strategy. I’m buying things I genuinely love and want on my wrist every day. That said, after years of deep research I have a pretty good instinct for value. The goal is to find something I’d want in my collection for a long time and that makes financial sense. Not one or the other.
When you’re drawn to a piece that fits your style but seems risky as an investment, how do you decide whether to buy?
I ask myself: would I be devastated if this lost value? If the answer is no, if I love it enough to own it purely for the joy of wearing it, then it’s probably worth it. What I try to avoid is buying something purely on investment logic without an emotional connection, because that’s just anxiety in watch form. I’d rather own thirty pieces I love than chase something I don’t personally connect with because someone said it was going up.
What budget rules do you set for yourself when acquiring vintage watches that match your personality?
I only buy what I can genuinely afford at that moment, not what I hope to afford after a future sale. Beyond that, I give myself the three-week rule. If I’m still thinking about a piece after three weeks, I can buy it. That said, vintage watches are often one-of-one, and sometimes you simply have to jump. On those special occasions, I do.
Above Benjamin’s vintage watches (Photo: courtesy of Georgia Benjamin)
Benjamin’s vintage watches (Photo: courtesy of Georgia Benjamin)
1 / 1
Which research and authentication steps do you personally never skip before adding a vintage watch to your collection?
Research is genuinely my favourite part of the process. One thing I never skip is trying to find an original archive or vintage [advertisement] that confirms the piece was actually part of that brand’s history. If I’m buying a Piaget dial I’ve never seen before, I want to verify [that] it existed, and it’s in their repertoire, not something assembled [later]. Beyond that, I always test for timing and movement, and I’ll send photos to dealer friends who are more versed in a particular brand when I can. There’s a saying I always come back to: trust the dealer, not the watch. Buying from a reputable dealer or auction house is normally a good bet, and if you’re able to open the caseback and check the movement yourself, that’s usually a very good sign.
How do your day-to-day life and wardrobe influence which vintage watches you wear, keep and sell?
People always ask: is it watch first, or outfit first? For me, it’s kind of both. Depending on what I’m doing that day or what mood I’m in, I’ll have a watch in mind, but either way, you can guarantee I’m always wearing one. I’m a thematic dresser. Whether I’m in Vegas, LA, or New York, my wardrobe adapts to be more evocative of that local energy and my watches follow suit. I buy things I genuinely love, I rarely want to sell. What I hold is anything with a personal story attached. What I’ve moved on from tends to be pieces I bought because they were a good deal rather than because I truly connected with them. Collecting with taste means being honest about when something isn’t really yours, even if it’s objectively a great watch.
What advice would you give other collectors who want to build a vintage watch collection that reflects who they are?
Learn as much as you can, but filter everything through your own taste. Figure out what you like and what you’re going to wear every day, and don’t get distracted by the noise around you. And don’t ask for anyone’s opinion. If a watch is giving you an emotional reaction, you’re the only one who’s going to know that. Asking someone else to justify a purchase usually means you don’t want it enough. Move on. Buy things that stop you in your tracks, buy things with stories, and don’t rush. The research is half the joy.
Topics
As the Regional Editor for Watches and Jewellery and Editorial Content Lead for Tatler GMT, Amrita Katara specialises in luxury watch and jewellery coverage across Asia, with expertise in editorial strategy, feature writing and interviews with industry leaders. Her past roles span luxury lifestyle media and client partnerships. Based in Mumbai, Amrita’s work bridges global trends and Asian market insights.
Curated for you
The stories, profiles, and cultural moments featured on our Instagram feed
