The full spectrum of Jane Austen screen adaptations: what to watch (and what to skip)

Directed by celebrated Taiwanese director Ang Lee from an adapted screenplay by Emma Thompson (that won the Academy Award for Best Adapted Screenplay), Sense and Sensibility was a hit with critics and audiences alike. The movie perfectly captures Regency-era romance, humour and the central themes of Austen’s work thanks to not just the superb direction and screenplay but also the cast, led by Emma Thompson, Kate Winslet, Hugh Grant and Alan Rickman.

And just as the BBC’s Pride and Prejudice made Colin Firth a Regency sex symbol, 1995’s Sense and Sensibility made Alan Rickman, who plays noble Colonel Brandon, the object of the Jane Austen fandom’s affection and devotion.

Don’t miss: 5 Ang Lee movies—from ‘Life of Pi’ to ‘Brokeback Mountain’—everyone should watch at least once

This adaptation plays up the will-they, won’t-they tension between Anne Elliot and Captain Wentworth who, after being torn apart by classist nonsense, must find their way back to each other. Amanda Root’s Anne is shy and intelligent and Ciaran Hinds’s Wentworth is proud and reticent. And their quiet portrayals perfectly convey the passionate restraint and yearning the two characters feel as they are continuously kept apart. 

As an adaptation of Emma, Clueless deftly updates Jane Austen’s novel to the ’90s while also definitively representing that decade—its fashion, culture and slang. It honours the spirit of the original while establishing itself as a timeless classic in its own right. 

In this adaptation, Alicia Silverstone plays Cher, a well-meaning but clueless matchmaking busybody intent on bringing people together despite what they think and feel. Silverstone brings warmth, depth and nuance to a character that could have easily felt one-note in less capable hands. Her charm and comedic timing elevate Cher into an iconic character. 

Think of Clueless as Jane Austen by way of teen movies. And what’s so special about it is that it gets both exactly right. On top of the smart script and crisp direction, the movie is also praised for the chemistry of its young cast, which includes a young Paul Rudd.

Just as Clueless succeeded in translating Austen for modern times, the 1996 adaptation of Emma succeeds in bringing the modern-day sensibility of rom-com to the Regency era. Light on its feet and delightful to watch, the film features clever dialogue, sharp editing and a charming performance from Gwyneth Paltrow as Emma. Her chemistry with Jeremy Northam’s dashing Mr Knightley draws you in and sells you on the romance. 

The rest of the cast, which includes Toni Collette, Ewan McGregor, Alan Cumming, Greta Scacchi, Juliet Stevenson and Polly Walker, also delivers exceptional performances.

See also: Gwyneth Paltrow on Her Beauty Philosophy, Self-Care Tips and More

In case you’re taking notes, this is the third Emma adaptation in a span of two years. This time, a young pre-Underworld Kate Beckinsale takes on the role of the ton’s misguided matchmaker. While Paltrow’s Emma plays up the romantic comedy, this adaptation is a little more subdued. That said, Beckinsale still plays the character with as much charm as her predecessor, albeit a little more grounded and restrained.

More a bold retelling than a faithful adaptation, 1999’s Mansfield Park is known to have incorporated Jane Austen’s letters and journals into the story of Fanny Price. While some purists decry the deviation from the source material, most appreciate the addition and how it enriches the story and Fanny’s character, stripping the former of the usual sheen given to Austen adaptations and making the latter far feistier than most of her Regency-era heroines. 

Bridget Jones’s Diary started as a regular newspaper column in The Independent in 1995. Inspired by Austen’s Pride and Prejudice, it chronicled the misadventures of London singleton Bridget Jones. The column became so popular that it was adapted into a novel a year later and in 2001, into a movie starring Reneé Zellweger, Colin Firth and Hugh Grant.

In a major meta moment, Colin Firth was cast as Bridget’s love interest, Mark Darcy, a character inspired by both Austen’s Mr Darcy and Firth’s portrayal of Mr Darcy in the BBC’s 1995 adaptation of Pride and Prejudice.

The movie remains one of the most beloved romantic comedies of all time and has spawned three sequels, the latest one having just been released earlier this year.

Don’t miss: From ‘The White Lotus’ to ‘Bridget Jones’, why Leo Woodall is the next big thing

Celebrating 20 years this year is the second definitive Pride and Prejudice adaptation on this list. It’s so celebrated that filming locations have become set-jetting destinations for fans from all over the world. Scenes have been closely dissected, with every eye flick and gesture analysed. Matthew Macfadyen’s iconic hand-flex scene, in particular, has enjoyed a lasting cultural impact and is often cited as the inspiration for most of the modern-day romantic hand acting that followed—often imitated but never surpassed. 

Keira Knightley and Macfadyen’s slow-burn chemistry has fans swooning to this day. Their disastrous proposal scene is a classic display of the kind of yearning that has kept the movie such a beloved fan favourite 20 years on. 

Here’s a bit of trivia about the movie: it has two endings. One had the original ending screened pretty much everywhere, and the other had a post-wedding scene that was mainly released for American audiences.

This adaptation of Jane Austen’s satiric take on Gothic novels stars a young Felicity Jones as Catherine Morland and JJ Feild as Henry Tilney. Fans and critics agree that the casting was inspired—Jones brings the right amount of innocence, charm and humour that the role requires. However, they also agree that the made-for-TV movie feels rushed and that it leaned too heavily on the gothic themes, losing a bit of the fun that made the book on which it was based a pointed parody of Gothic tropes.

This time, it’s Romola Garai, who delivers a standout performance as the lively and headstrong Emma Woodhouse, a role that earned her a well-deserved nomination for a Golden Globe Award. She plays opposite Jonny Lee Miller as the charming and upstanding Mr Knightley. Together, their chemistry sparkles in this remake, delivering the kind of swoony romance you can’t help but root for.

Not so much an adaptation of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice as an adaptation of a book that was inspired by it. Pride and Prejudice and Zombies adds, you guessed it, zombies into the mix. It stars Lily James as a combat-ready Elizabeth Bennet and Sam Riley as the zombie-hunting Mr Darcy. Other cast members include Suki Waterhouse, Bella Heathcote and Douglas Booth. 

The genre-bending movie gives our favourite Austen characters something new to do. Instead of just playing cards in the drawing room or attending balls, they’re also slicing through the undead. If you’re looking for something fun and silly, this adaptation is entertaining enough watch.

Kate Beckinsale returns to Austenland in Love & Friendship, adapted from the novella Lady Susan, one of Jane Austen’s lesser-known works. Beckinsale plays the scheming and manipulative Lady Susan, a widow who is on the hunt for an advantageous marriage for her daughter…and herself. 

Praised for the charming performance of its cast, particularly Beckinsale, as well as the clever way it tackles class and marriage, it is considered one of the better Jane Austen adaptations.

Although Anya Taylor-Joy can hardly do no wrong and turns in a brilliant performance as everyone’s favourite Regency-era matchmaker, the movie could use a bit more warmth and depth. The pace, too, could have been better. 

However, the 2020 adaptation is not without its charms. Beyond Taylor-Joy’s magnetic screen presence, the film is a visual feast—its pastel-hued costumes and ornate sets are a confectioner’s delight. But fans may find that this only serves to highlight that the movie is more style than substance.

See also: Exclusive: Anya Taylor-Joy on wanting to trek the Himalayas, her favourite role and the moon’s power

The 2022 Netflix adaptation of Persuasion failed to impress critics and audiences. It attempts to blend the Regency era with modern sensibilities, and the result is neither here nor there. It’s a shame since Dakota Johnson, who stars as Anne Elliot, has both the charm and comedic timing to truly shine in the role. 

Another misstep is having Johnson regularly break the fourth wall, a narrative device brilliantly employed in and popularised by Fleabag. But where in Fleabag, it served the story and felt natural, in 2022’s Persuasion, it felt more like a cheap trick.

NOW READ

Recreate Dakota Johnson’s Rosy Pink Make-Up Look, As Seen in Netflix’s ‘Persuasion’

From Page to Screen: 6 Wattpad movie adaptations that might surprise you

8 best on-screen adaptations of Pulitzer Prize-winning novels