Cover This month’s debate surrounds toxic fandoms (Photo L-R: Affa Chan/Tatler Hong Kong, courtesy of Kiri T, Instagram/@jayfungmusic)
This month’s debate surrounds toxic fandoms (Photo L-R: Affa Chan/Tatler Hong Kong, courtesy of Kiri T, Instagram/@jayfungmusic)
1 / 1
Singer-songwriters Kiri T and Jay Fung go head-to-head with Lindsey McAlister, artist and founder of the Hong Kong Youth Arts Foundation, to discuss toxic fandoms
Kiri T says: Yes
“I do believe there is such a thing as a toxic fandom. I think this tends to happen whenever fans are overly attached to their idols. It’s a tough balance, because while a supportive community is beautiful, there are bound to be conflicts and differences, which can turn sour when not managed properly. I think any type of fanatical behaviour—whether bullying or trolling—is unhealthy. However, I also do think that it’s inevitable. Just like any bell curve, there will always be outliers to the majority. I don’t believe that any of these fans were born with ill intentions but they are probably longing for a connection with the artist. Musicians can play a part in keeping their fans in check [by urging them to] act civilly.”
Jay Fung says: Yes
“Yes. Although celebrities and artists are public figures, I believe that they too are just regular people who have personal lives, families and things they may prefer to keep to themselves. When fans engage in behaviour that is considered unacceptable and possibly even harmful, especially if it disrupts privacy, then yes, I do believe there is such a thing as toxic fandom.”
Lindsey McAlister says: No
“The concept of toxic fandom tends to unfairly generalise the actions of a small minority of an entire fanbase. In youth and community arts, where the core base of supporters is typically close-knit and highly invested in positive outcomes, the argument that there is no such thing as toxic fandom may hold more weight. These environments often prioritise collaboration, education and personal development, fostering a supportive and nurturing atmosphere. Supporters in these spaces are generally motivated by a shared commitment to community improvement and youth empowerment, which reduces the likelihood of the aggressive, demanding and harassing behaviours characteristic of toxic fandom. As a result, the focus on collective goals and personal growth in youth and community arts can mitigate the conditions that typically give rise to toxic fan behaviour.”
As Content Director at Tatler Hong Kong, Tara shapes the brand's editorial vision across social, digital and print. She also drives the planning and execution of Tatler's flagship IPs. In her dual role as Head of VIP, she reports on Asia's most influential figures — from CEOs and leaders across business, style and the arts — curates star-studded events, and builds the relationships and communities that define the brand. Born and raised in the Middle East, she honed her craft in Dubai, crafting communication strategies for luxury brands across the Gulf. Follow her on Instagram @tarasobti.
