The writer gets candid about the egg freezing ban in Singapore and shares her thoughts on the topic

I rarely get upset.

OK, that’s not true. I got extremely upset when my cat knocked my coffee over the other morning—what I meant to say is that I rarely get upset at things I read about in the press. After all, the news is hardly ever presented to represent both truths, and having worked in both PR and advertising, I can smell a fluff piece from a mile away.

But recently, I was fuming. In hindsight, it must have looked pretty funny. I remember stomping around the house, reading the article out loud at a volume that was definitely louder than necessary, my husband nervously looking on, unsure whether it was safe to engage. The cats were nowhere in sight—a sure sign that Mum was pissed off.

The article is the now-infamous piece by AFP titled “Singapore egg-freezing ban forces women to head overseas”.

Egg freezing leads to social and ethical issues… and is “profoundly selfish”.

So in case you didn’t know, social egg freezing is banned in Singapore. You can only undergo the procedure if you have certain medical reasons, for example, needing chemotherapy which could adversely affect your fertility.

I am fortunate that I do not have any of the medical reasons that would qualify me. Instead, I just have a lot of frustration.

I looked into egg freezing in early 2019, so I’ve always known it was banned. But until recently, I wasn’t aware that wanting to freeze my eggs makes me not just “profoundly selfish”, but also a contributor to certain “social and ethical issues” in Singapore.

Excuse me?

These were the words of the National Council of Churches of Singapore (NCCS) and Ministry of Social and Family Development (MSF) respectively, not mine. I was baffled. I was angry. I felt unjustly accused. How does my wanting to prolong my fertility make me selfish? By freezing my eggs and giving myself a shot at motherhood when I’m older, doesn’t that actually help our declining birth rates? Doesn’t the ban essentially mean that I have to find the right partner, get married and pop a kid in my early 30s? What about my career? And beyond all else, it’s my body, why don’t I have the right to decide what to do with it? 

Tatler Asia

But I’m just an ordinary citizen, so I wondered if perhaps, there was a bigger picture I was not seeing. I needed to reach out to the community and hear their frustrations, and I needed to research the reasons why the ban is in place.

So I did what any millennial would do—start an Instagram page (@myeggsmytime) in hopes of creating discourse. I had all but five followers at the beginning, but after reaching out to several prominent local activists’ pages, the account quickly grew and connected me with women from all walks of life, and their stories.

Stories that both inspired me, and broke my heart. But more importantly, stories that made me realise this was a conversation that needed to be louder.  

Time is not on our side

There are women with financial capabilities who have already gone overseas to freeze their eggs because they felt like they were running out of time.

There are women who had plans to go overseas to freeze their eggs, but Covid-19 border restrictions are keeping them stuck in Singapore, and now time is running out.

There are women who have wanted children since they were children, but have yet to meet the right person and now find that time is no longer on their side.

There are women who are ready to have children but because of the elderly parents they have to care for, simply can’t afford the time now. 

There are women who want to have children later in life, but are fully aware of the financial responsibility that comes with starting a family, and so have decided to put their careers first. They don’t have a lot of time left. 

There are women in their early 20s who are still in school and have yet to enter the workforce. They’re still trying to figure life out, but they’ve already figured out that the time they have now won’t last forever.

Let’s face it. Our fertility drastically decreases every year that we get older. In my mid-20s, I only have 20 per cent of my eggs left, and not all of them are even usable. In my 30s, I only have a 20 per cent chance of getting pregnant, and in my 40s, that likelihood plummets to just 5 per cent. If these figures are not depressing enough, may I remind you that it is statistically proven that the remaining eggs in older women are more likely to have abnormal chromosomes, which further reduces the likelihood of pregnancy. By the laws of nature, women are pitted against a cruel biological clock that ticks louder every year that we are not dating, married or pregnant.

If anything, we are profoundly selfless. For many women, we feel a need to delay motherhood because we know just how difficult it is, mentally and financially, to raise a kid. We want the best for our future children and if that means freezing our eggs and waiting a few years until we are able to provide to the best of our abilities, then… why not? Why are we not utilising the advantages of science? As a species, we’ve always used technology to make our lives better. Why are we drawing a line here?

Educate before you legislate

According to an MSF media room statement, the Government “(has) to take into account the ethical and social concerns over legalising social egg freezing, including inadvertently causing more to delay marriage or parenthood based on a misperception that they can have a child whenever they wish to. The risks of developing complications during pregnancy also increase with age, even if the child is conceived through a frozen egg.”

But do I not have a smartphone and by extension, access to all the knowledge under the sun, at my disposal? Would I really not do all the research I can before electing to undergo a seriously invasive procedure that requires a lot of money, two weeks of hormone injections and a whole host of potential side effects after? This is not ordering dinner on a food delivery platform for crying out loud—even that, I will usually research extensively before deciding on a restaurant. This line of reasoning is incredibly presumptuous and makes no sense for one simple reason: education.

Prior to undergoing IVF treatments or abortions, counselling is mandated by law. Surely we can do the same for egg freezing if the ban were to be lifted? If we are encouraged and trusted to have children, why are we being treated like children? 

Tatler Asia

My eggs, my time, My eggs, my choice

Finally, I would like to address the assumption that legalising egg freezing would cause women to delay marriage and parenthood. I have news for you: women are already delaying marriage without egg freezing being legal. In fact, Channel News Asia recently reported that singlehood “has become more prevalent across multiple age groups over the last decade”.   

The argument that legalising egg freezing will cause women to delay marriage is incredibly problematic because it posits that the only goal of marriage is childbirth and that the only important role of women in society is to deliver babies. There are many married couples who choose not to have children (environmental issues, overpopulation etc) and there are many single women who would be more than happy to raise a child on their own… when she is ready. There are also many single women who choose not to get married or have kids because their careers are their calling.

I understand that Singapore holds on to its conservative values but if we want to actually be a progressive, first-world nation, then we need to acknowledge and accept that the traditional familial structure is changing, and adapt accordingly.  

I agree that social egg freezing is a larger issue and not as simple as “my body, my choice”. (Although that being said, cigarettes and alcohol have been legal for centuries now so…)

A few weeks ago I had the opportunity to chat with egg freezing advocate, MP Cheng Li Hui, and she mentioned several points I hadn’t thought of. For instance, if we legalise egg freezing, will it be purely privately funded, or will the government offer a subsidy? If so, is the choice to delay pregnancy the responsibility of the taxpayer? There are, indubitably, many other issues surrounding social egg freezing that needs discussing before we can take steps to legalise it, and the conversation is going to be a long one, but don’t forget that at the crux of it, this is a conversation about women’s rights.

Is that not a conversation worth having?


Emma Zhang is a content strategist specialising in all things digital. @myeggsmytime is the first time she’s marrying her work skills with something personal, and she hopes the page will create change for the next generation. 

Topics