Emma Stone as Bella Baxter in Yorgos Lanthimos' 'Poor Things'
Cover Emma Stone as Bella Baxter in Yorgos Lanthimos’s ‘Poor Things’
Emma Stone as Bella Baxter in Yorgos Lanthimos' 'Poor Things'

Is 'Poor Things' truly feminist? Here’s our humble take on this award-winning movie

Poor Things was a myriad of things, but was it a feminist movie? Empowering on some parts, but not enough to be labelled as such. What Yorgos Lanthimos brought to the table, however, was a comical coming-of-age story that offered a satirical commentary on societal norms and expectations. 

Personal considerations influenced Poor Things’s omission from the feminist category. I found its convictions spiralling out of control especially when external forces, predominantly men, largely shape Baxter’s journey of self-discovery. 

In case you missed it: Tatler Review: Why People Hated The Ending Of ‘Promising Young Woman’ (2020)

Tatler Asia
Emma Stone and Mark Ruffalo in Yorgos Lanthimos' 'Poor Things'
Above Emma Stone and Mark Ruffalo in Yorgos Lanthimos's 'Poor Things' (Photo: Searchlight Pictures)
Emma Stone and Mark Ruffalo in Yorgos Lanthimos' 'Poor Things'

A toddler trapped within the confines of a twenty-something-year-old female body, Bella Baxter (Emma Stone) takes us on a whimsical journey around Europe with her innocence and hilarious takes on love, sex, nihilism, and... apples. 

In a series of black-and-white scenes, eccentric doctor Godwin “God” Baxter (Willem Dafoe) essentially seizes control of her body for his experimental use. This alone shows that although God implies his paternal affection for Bella, he has never really seen her as his own. He cares whether the latter would develop into something less or more than what she was created to be.

In the next few segments, Bella’s every choice is instigated by men. For instance, her desire to explore the world was influenced by Duncan (Mark Ruffalo) who takes advantage of her guilelessness for his sexual needs.

More from Tatler: Deleter (2022): a movie of missed opportunities?

Tatler Asia
Emma Stone as Bella Baxter in Yorgos Lanthimos' 'Poor Things'
Above Emma Stone as Bella Baxter in Yorgos Lanthimos's 'Poor Things' (Photo: Searchlight Pictures)
Emma Stone as Bella Baxter in Yorgos Lanthimos' 'Poor Things'

The latter half of the film merely affirms the statement above. Somewhere along Bella’s adventure, she meets Harry Astley (Jerrod Carmichael) and Martha von Kurtzroc (Hanna Schygulla) who inspires her to take an eager interest in philosophy. 

Astley takes Bella to the slums and presents the world from a nihilistic perspective. This, in return, gives birth to Bella’s idealism:

Bella: We must go help them.

AstleyHow will we do that? When we go down there, they’ll quite rightfully rope us, rob us, and rape us. And if they were here, and we were there, we'd do the same to them.

Two male tricksters took advantage of Bella’s endeavour to assist the poor through Duncan’s gambling income.

 

Tatler Asia
Bella Baxter (Emma Stone) attempts to help the poor through Duncan's gambling money
Above Bella Baxter (Emma Stone) attempts to help the poor through Duncan's gambling money (Photo: Searchlight Pictures)
Bella Baxter (Emma Stone) attempts to help the poor through Duncan's gambling money

In Paris, Bella finds a brothel and meets Madame Swiney (Kathryn Hunter), a tattoed lady who also exploits her childlike naïveté and profits from her sexual liberation. This, supposedly, opens the character’s search for sexual agency, but ultimately in doing so, the men she gratifies are the very people who determine what she experiences. 

Lest we forget, some groups took advantage of female liberation in the past. Such were pornographers in the seventies who viewed women’s unrestricted sexual expression as always consenting. 

See also: ‘Bawat Bonggang Bagay’ tells us to stop avoiding the topic of mental health

Above Yorgos Lanthimos's ‘Poor Things’ trailer

In the end, she returns to God’s home and confronts him about her origins. The film opts not to condemn him but rather fosters forgiveness in the name of his deteriorating health and Bella’s love. 

All points considered, the film veers away from the feminist angles for which it was supposedly praised. Feminism, in a broad sense, is challenging the system that puts women’s choices at the curb. Just because a female lead chooses to do something, does not inherently qualify the act as feminist.

In Poor Things, I find little to no resolute adherence to feminist principles—Bella was devoid of freedom from the moment she was “born” and her ways of turning the table have so far been meddled with demands from patriarchy.

What it got right

I give credit where it is due: Bella’s defiance of social norms is empowering; one scene, in particular, made the whole cinema erupt in laughter: after making love with Duncan, she mulls over the fact that sex is exhilarating. She takes an innocent jab at the latter for being unable to do it repeatedly (the way women can). 

In the movie, it was but a line for comic relief, beyond the screen, it was an insult to male biology.

Audiences are bound to find similar instances in this surprisingly dark yet witty narrative. Regardless of whether its creators aimed for such humour, Poor Things proved to be noticeably funnier than other comedies within its genre. 

Related: Opinion: Remembering the origins of International Women’s Day is key to our feminism today

Tatler Asia
Emma Stone and Yorgos Lanthimos (Photo: Dazed)
Above Emma Stone and Yorgos Lanthimos in Poor Things (Photo: Dazed)
Emma Stone and Yorgos Lanthimos (Photo: Dazed)

Lanthimos succeeded in creating a faithful adaptation of this story by Alasdair Gray. The filmmaker built an otherworldly, technicolour space that provides a feeling of wonder. 

As of this post, the movie has been bagging awards and praises—something it truly deserves considering the daring visuals, sharp comebacks, and occasional chuckles its characters have provided throughout.

NOW READ 

How ‘Tick, Tick… Boom!’ perfectly communicates the anxiety of time running out

5 Essential Reads On Feminism In The 21st Century

8 inspiring Filipinas you probably haven’t met until now

Jove Moya
Senior Feature Writer, Tatler Philippines
Tatler Asia

Jove holds a degree in Journalism and is currently pursuing graduate studies in Philosophy at the University of the Philippines–Diliman. She has flair for in-depth, interview-driven stories that explore politics and culture, shaped by her background in national broadsheets. 

When she’s not on assignment, Jove spends her days painting, sipping lemonade, and walking her dog, Jupiter. She can often be seen in Escolta with a film camera in hand, browsing novelty shops in search of rare memorabilia. For leads, reach her at Jove@tatlerphilippines.com.