Cover These C-drama heroines prove that the wrong man can look very convincing...at least until the plot reveals what he’s really made of (Photo: YouKu)
These C-drama heroines prove that the wrong man can look very convincing...at least until the plot reveals what he’s really made of (Photo: YouKu)
1 / 1
Sometimes the wrong man looks perfect on paper, sometimes he arrives at exactly the wrong moment and sometimes the heroine has to make a spectacularly bad romantic decision before she figures out what she actually wants
Sometimes the red flag isn’t subtle. Sometimes she is standing directly in front of it, making wedding plans. C-drama romances are full of women who choose the wrong man for reasons that make perfect sense at the time: ambition, family pressure, first love, misplaced trust or simply believing that chemistry can compensate for everything else. Or maybe the other guy was just a more handsome actor. But here? These are the heroines whose romantic decisions had us yelling at the screen—not because we did not understand why they chose him, but because we could see exactly where it was going.
In case you missed it: Hard-to-resist: 8 greenest red flags in C-dramas
Jin Mi in ‘Ashes of Love’ (2018)
Above She couldn’t understand love, he couldn’t let go of it and somewhere between the two, everything went spectacularly wrong
The wrong choice: Xufeng
Jin Mi (Yang Zi) begins Ashes of Love with an enormous romantic disadvantage: she has been given the Unfeeling Pill, leaving her unable to understand romantic love. Into her life come two brothers who could hardly be more different—Xufeng (Deng Lun), the fiery and charismatic Fire God, and Runyu (Luo Yunxi), the quieter Night Deity who initially appears gentler and more patient.
It is easy to understand why Jin Mi is drawn to Xufeng. Their relationship is passionate, complicated and increasingly impossible to ignore. Runyu, meanwhile, appears to offer something altogether different: patience, protection and a seemingly quieter kind of devotion.
The problem is that Runyu’s tragedy eventually becomes part of the reason he is the wrong choice. His childhood trauma, his mother’s death and his lifelong position as the overlooked son of the Heavenly Emperor shape his desperate desire to have something he can call his own. His love for Jin Mi gradually becomes tangled up with fear, jealousy and the need to control his own fate.
Jin Mi choosing Xufeng isn’t simply a case of picking the “better” man. The drama deliberately makes both relationships complicated. But by the time Jin Mi finally understands what love actually means, the consequences of all their choices have become impossible to undo.
See more: 8 C-dramas that made us fall in love with the second male lead
Sheng Minglan in ‘The Story of Minglan’ (2018)
Above He was her first love, her perfect match on paper and exactly the wrong man for the life Minglan needed to survive
The wrong choice: Qi Heng—at least for the life she eventually wanted
Sheng Minglan (Zhao Liying) does not exactly make the classic “wrong man” choice. In fact, The Story of Minglan is more interesting because it shows us why the right-looking man can still be wrong.
When Minglan falls for Qi Heng (Zhu Yilong), he seems almost ideal: handsome, sincere, kind and genuinely devoted to her. He is also the son of a powerful noble family and therefore, theoretically, capable of giving her a life far above the one she could expect as the daughter of a concubine.
But Minglan understands something Qi Heng does not: love exists inside a social system that can crush people who underestimate it. Qi Heng loves her, but he cannot overcome his family’s expectations. His parents oppose the match and eventually force him to marry a princess. Minglan, meanwhile, has spent her entire life learning that survival depends on anticipating danger rather than trusting promises.
Gu Tingye (Feng Shaofeng), for all his complications, eventually offers something Qi Heng cannot: the ability to stand beside Minglan within the brutal social and political world she has learned to navigate.
This is one of the most bittersweet “wrong man” stories on the list. Minglan didn’t choose badly. She learned that being loved isn’t the same as being protected by the life that comes with that love.
Cheng Shaoshang in ‘Love Like the Galaxy’ (2022)
Above Three men, three possible futures and one heroine who has to figure out what kind of life she actually wants
The wrong choices: Lou Yao and, arguably, everyone before Ling Buyi
Cheng Shaoshang (Zhao Lusi) is practically designed for romantic indecision. Abandoned by her parents while they went to war, she grows up under the care of relatives who neglect and mistreat her, forcing her to become observant, pragmatic and fiercely self-reliant.
Then she encounters three very different men: Lou Yao (Yu Cheng’en), the gentle aristocrat who offers stability; Yuan Shen (Li Yunrui), the clever and frustrating scholar who matches her intellectually; and Ling Buyi (Wu Lei), the Emperor’s formidable foster son whose secrets pull her into a far more dangerous world.
Lou Yao is arguably the first “wrong” choice. Shaoshang genuinely likes him, but their engagement exposes just how poorly suited they are to the realities surrounding them. His family obligations and her inability to fit comfortably into their world eventually make the relationship unsustainable.
Ling Buyi is another matter entirely. He is the man Shaoshang ultimately chooses, but he comes with secrets, vengeance and a capacity for violence that makes the relationship anything but safe. The drama’s central romance therefore becomes less about finding the perfect man than about Shaoshang discovering what she values enough to accept the risks that come with it.
Which is perhaps why this is such a good example of the trope: the wrong man isn’t always the one she leaves. Sometimes he’s the one you spend the entire drama wondering whether she should have left.
Feng Zhiwei in ‘The Rise of Phoenixes’ (2018)
Above They were intellectually perfect for each other, which is precisely why falling in love was such a terrible idea
The wrong choice: Ning Yi
Feng Zhiwei (Ni Ni) and Ning Yi (Chen Kun) may be one of the most intellectually matched couples in C-drama, which makes their romantic catastrophe all the more painful.
Zhiwei disguises herself as a man, enters Qingming Academy and rises through the political world on the strength of her intelligence. Ning Yi, meanwhile, is a calculating prince who has spent years concealing his true ambitions while building his network of influence. Their attraction grows because they see something in each other that almost nobody else can: an equal mind.
The problem is that their personal histories make their relationship politically poisonous. Zhiwei eventually discovers that she is surviving royalty from the previous dynasty—the very dynasty Ning Yi’s family helped destroy. Her love for him therefore collides directly with her desire for revenge.
This is not a case of a heroine choosing a charming idiot over a perfectly decent man. Ning Yi is brilliant, loyal to his own ambitions and genuinely in love with her. He is also inseparable from the political world that destroyed the people she loved.
Their tragedy is therefore almost cruelly elegant: they find someone who understands them intellectually, emotionally and politically, only to discover that understanding someone does not mean you can forgive what they represent.
See more: Green flags only: 9 healthiest relationships in C-dramas we’d actually root for
Xiao Feng in ‘Goodbye My Princess’ (2019)
Above She fell in love with a man before she knew that the man she loved was also the person who could destroy her world
The wrong choice: Li Chengyin
Xiao Feng (Peng Xiaoran) begins as the princess of the Western Liang and becomes entangled with Gu Xiaowu, a mysterious young man she meets while living away from the political centre. What she doesn’t know is that Gu Xiaowu is actually Li Chengyin (Chen Xingxu), the fifth prince of the Eastern Palace.
Their romance is doomed almost from the moment it begins because their personal relationship is inseparable from a political struggle neither of them can escape. Li Chengyin’s identity, ambitions and position eventually collide with Xiao Feng’s family and homeland, transforming what once felt like an adventurous love story into an extraordinary tragedy.
What makes Xiao Feng’s choice so painful is that she doesn’t fall for Li Chengyin because she wants power. She falls for the man she believes he is when they are away from the court.
The revelation that her beloved and her political enemy are the same person destroys the distinction she had been relying on. This is certainly one of the cruellest versions of the trope.
Xue Fangfei in ‘The Double’ (2024)
Above She thought she married a brilliant young scholar with a promising future. She didn’t realise how much that future would eventually cost her
The wrong choice: Shen Yurong
Xue Fangfei (Wu Jinyan) enters her marriage to Shen Yurong (Liang Yongqi), believing she has found a sincere and ambitious young scholar whose future she is willing to help build. Her family supports the marriage, and Fangfei stands behind his aspirations.
But when Shen Yurong’s political ambitions collide with the circumstances surrounding their marriage, the man she trusted becomes complicit in the attempt to destroy her. Fangfei survives being buried alive and eventually assumes the identity of Jiang Li, returning to society with revenge on her mind.
What makes her original choice so painful is that Shen Yurong isn’t presented as an obvious monster from the beginning. Fangfei’s faith in him is genuine precisely because she has every reason to believe in the person he appears to be.
Her revenge therefore isn’t simply about punishing a bad husband. It is about confronting the horrifying possibility that the person you trusted most was someone you never really knew. And that might be the most dangerous wrong choice of all.
Topics
Sasha Lim Uy Mariposa is a lifestyle journalist who is known for her food writing. Based in Manila and currently a marketing content specialist, she still dabbles in entertainment, beauty and dining coverage. She was the former managing editor of Esquire Philippines and was the food editor at SPOT.ph. She also edited several best-selling books about food.
She now writes for the different Tatler Asia markets as a contributing writer for T-Labs.
