Miro’s ‘Sans Titre’ (1947) (Photo: courtesy Sotheby’s)
Cover Miro’s ‘Sans Titre’ (1947) (Photo: courtesy Sotheby’s)

International auction houses are expanding their presence in Hong Kong and Asia - what does this mean for the future of the Asian art market?

Alex Branczik is as elated as he is exhausted. Sotheby’s Asia’s senior director and chairman, modern & contemporary art, has a lot to be pleased about. Following a buzzy, event-filled Art Week hailing the return of Art Basel Hong Kong and international visitors, Sotheby’s spring marquee sales, which took place in April, hauled in HK$3.71 billion, and set 21 new auction records. Although it wasn’t anywhere near the HK$10 billion the auction house made from its record 2021 sales, it was still considered a post-pandemic victory and a cause for celebration. 

In fact, the pandemic seems to have had little negative effect on the art world or market. “The market was really robust in 2021 and 2022,” notes Yuki Terase, Sotheby’s former head of contemporary art, who now heads up art consultancy Art Intelligence Global. “I think the concern now is: when are we going to see the correction come? Because what usually happens is that the art world lags behind; when the financial market goes down, the art market is the last to go down and first one to come out [of recession].” Multiple auction houses saw record sales in 2021, which continued into 2022, and many record prices were achieved.

Tatler Asia
Alex Branczik, Sotheby's Asia Senior Director and Chairman Modern and Contemporary Art  (Photo: Sotheby's)
Above Alex Branczik, Sotheby's Asia Senior Director and Chairman Modern and Contemporary Art (Photo: Sotheby's)
Tatler Asia
Francis Belin, President of Christies Asia (Photo: Christie's Images)
Above Francis Belin, President of Christies Asia (Photo: Christie's Images)

In April, UBS released its annual art market report; among its latest findings based on statistics from 2022 was that the market grew by 3 per cent, restoring it to its 2019, pre-pandemic value. In large part this was due to resumption of in-person events such as art fairs and auctions. Sales for the auction sector were down by 2 per cent compared to 2021, but still up by 11 per cent compared to 2019. While mainland China and Hong Kong experienced lower sales in 2022 due to pandemic restrictions, collectors from the mainland were out in full force during Hong Kong’s 2023 Art Month, making up for lost opportunities. But while things seem to be on the up and up, the market report did speculate that this recent boom will soon cool off.

Branczik, whose new role came amid a company-wide reshuffling of staff (including Terase’s departure) and new hires in 2021—including Nathan Drahi’s appointment as managing director—attributes Sotheby’s performance and expansion to the auction house’s past management. “We’ve had this storied 50-year history in Asia, and the team today is indebted to past leaders who have brought us to where we are today,” he says. “What we’re doing now is laying the foundation for the next 50 years and putting in place a team that can execute a new business model.”

Tatler Asia
Yuki Terase, Founding Partner, Art Intelligence Global (Photo: Tory Ho)
Above Yuki Terase, Founding Partner, Art Intelligence Global (Photo: Tory Ho)
Tatler Asia
Jonathan Crockett, Chairman, Phillips Asia (Photo: Kwannam Chu)
Above Jonathan Crockett, Chairman, Phillips Asia (Photo: Kwannam Chu)

This new model involves a physical and operational expansion of the company that mirrors Asian collecting practices and tastes. In 2024, Sotheby’s will be relocating its offices and showrooms into a new 24,000 sq ft space in Chater House,Central, a move motivated by the need for a more flexible way of operating and conducting sales. Typically, auction houses have to rent halls in the Hong Kong Convention and Exhibition Centre or hotel function rooms to stage and conduct sales, which means they are “tied to selling everything all at once during two weeks of the year”, says Branczik.

Sotheby’s is not the only auction house expanding its presence in the city. Phillips inaugurated its new 50,000 sq ft space in March: six floors of offices, gallery spaces, a shop, café and VIP lounge in the building directly opposite the M+ museum. “The idea to create a permanent gallery allows us to hold year-round exhibitions and auctions,” says Jonathan Crockett, chairman, Asia, at Phillips. “Now, in Hong Kong, we can now operate a model that is along the same lines as the way auction houses operate in the west.”

Tatler Asia
Rendering of Christie's new office in the new Henderson building (Photo: courtesy Christie's Images)
Above Rendering of Christie's new office in the new Henderson building (Photo: courtesy Christie's Images)
Tatler Asia
Inside Phillips new Asia head quarters (Photo: Phillips)
Above Inside Phillips new Asia head quarters (Photo: Phillips)

Christie’s is relocating in 2024 from its two-floor space in Alexandra House to the new Henderson building designed by Zaha Hadid Architects in Central. “We can double what we have been doing at our current premises at Alexandra House and the Hong Kong Convention and Exhibition Centre, increasing our programme from 25 weeks of activities per year to activities all year round,” says Francis Belin, president of Christie’s Asia, adding that the change is “a response to the rapidly growing number of collectors in Asia”.

The expansion of the big three auction houses marks a new phase in Hong Kong’s development as an art and luxury commerce hub, and one that reflects the growth and changes that began before the pandemic and accelerated during it. “The market started maturing more pre-pandemic: it was changing, but that change was expedited during the pandemic, especially in Asia, which came into a second phase of collecting,” says Terase. The first phase of collecting prompted the boom in the Asian art market in the early 2000s, and gained steady momentum into the mid-2000s. It eventually resulted in the boom in the contemporary Chinese and Asian modern art market in the late 2000s and early 2010s, which saw the initial formation of an Asian market and collecting culture. “Initially, in the first phase [of collecting], people were buying on more of a whim, to fill their walls and homes; gradually that has got to a point now where [collectors] are building collections with a vision.” 

Tatler Asia
Inside Art Intelligence Global (Photo: courtesy AIG)
Above Inside Art Intelligence Global (Photo: courtesy AIG)

Terase’s decision to leave Sotheby’s and start her own consultancy was in large part an attempt to tap into the rise and maturation of the Asian art market and offer next-level services to her clients. Part of this maturation consister of collectors buying different kinds of art: while previously Chinese and Asian modern art had dominated auction sales, now western and contemporary art are becoming more prevalent. Asian collectors in particular have become much more international in their taste.

Terase recalls when she first moved to the city in 2014, “there was no western art in the sales, people were collecting much more regionally and no one outside of Hong Kong or Asia was paying attention to those sales. Fast- forward to when I left [Sotheby’s], and half of the sales revenue came from western art.” She attributes this to the changing collector base: “People are better informed, much younger and more experimental.”

Tatler Asia
Zhang Daqian's Pink Lotus on Gold Screen (1973) (Photo: courtesy Sotheby's)
Above Zhang Daqian's Pink Lotus on Gold Screen (1973) (Photo: courtesy Sotheby's)

Branczik agrees that there has been an obvious change in Asian collecting habits, and describes it as an expansion of taste: in Sotheby’s spring 2023 auction, Chinese art remained a strongly performing department, raking in HK$1.64 billion, the bulk of which came from the sale of modernist painter Zhang Daqian’s Pink Lotus on Gold Screen for HK$251.6 million (it was also the third highest price ever achieved for the artist at auction). Meanwhile, in the Modern and Contemporary Art section, Joan Miró’s Sans Titre achieved a new auction record, HK$50.6 million, for the artist in Asia, while Picasso’s portrait of his muse Françoise Gilot, Femme dans un Fauteuil, sold for HK$93.1m, and the incredibly popular contemporary artist Yoshitomo Nara’s In the Milky Lane led the Contemporary Art series at HK$100.6m.

“In many ways, it’s the transformation of a local market to a truly global one, in terms of the art that is collected, and indicative of the kind of clients who are based here and their collecting habits,” Branczik notes. “One thing that shouldn’t be overlooked is the role of Asian bidders in our other sale rooms, because they’re not just bidding in Hong Kong.” 

Tatler Asia
Picasso's Femme Dans Un Fauteuil (1948) (Photo: courtesy Sotheby's)
Above Picasso's Femme Dans Un Fauteuil (1948) (Photo: courtesy Sotheby's)

Belin makes a similar observation, reaffirming Asian collectors’ growing international presence. “We continue to see significant Asian buying power in our APAC and global sales room,” the Christie’s chairman says,
citing the US$1.8 billion that Asian clients contributed to its sale rooms globally, or 26 per cent of the total, their highest annual contribution by value since 2015.

As the auction houses physically expand their presence in Hong Kong, they’re also aiming to expand their operations to the rest of Asia. Christie’s has had a representative office in Shanghai since 1994, and
held its first auction there in 2013, and Sotheby’s is opening new offices in Shanghai and Seoul later this year and has hired new staff in Vietnam and Thailand. It will also continue to conduct auctions in Singapore. And Phillips’s spanking new Hong Kong space comes at a time when significant doubts over its financing were raised regarding the company’s ownership. While Crockett dismisses this as speculation, he says that the new space is indicative of “our long-term commitment to this region”, noting that the company has aggressively expanded in Asia in the past eight years, operating in Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, mainland China and Southeast Asia. “We’re not going anywhere.” 

Now Read

Hong Kong artist Vaevae Chan on building a cave in her studio, serendipity and healing

The first Central Asian textile art exhibition in the Greater China region wows Hong Kong

Meet Ola Maciejewska, the choreographer exploring the intersections between dance and sculpture

Topics